My assessment tool…
Information
A. Relevant and Credible i.e. trustworthy author and updated regularly.
B. Useful and Understandable.
Operational
A. Speed, Links
B. Features
Aesthetics
A. layout,
B. Colour scheme and readability
Much like mike’s each of these areas is scored 1-3 with 1 being poor and 3 being good, however my scoring system adds an additional score 1-5 for an overall feeling about the site from a; did it deliver to your expectations? Go below or beyond? point of view, this is to balance out weighting between the three areas of Information, Operational and Aesthetics this is because these areas can be of different importance to people. Secondly if a website accumulates three scores of 1 then 2 points are deducted from the total, this allows a greater ability to determine a website as truly awful.
The maximum score is 23
The lowest score is 2 (with 4 points deducted for accumulations of 1 point scores)
Good website; http://www.myspace.com/theirondoorclub
Information
A. Relevant and Credible i.e. trustworthy author and updated regularly. 2
B. Useful and Understandable. 2
Operational
A. Speed, Links 3
B. Features 3
Aesthetics
A. layout, 3
B. Colour scheme and readability 2
Overall feeling 4
Overall score 19
Thoughts: My-space is a well established website that is regularly policed by administrators and updated by its contributors. It is clear and easy to navigate due to being quite minimal. It supports a multitude of content, including video and audio, also if your computer does not have the facilities to use some of the content it will talk you through downloading applicable software. Each registered user can fully personalise their page (this of course can be bad and good). In addition its search engine is Google powered. The site does not suffer from pop ups although advertising is creeping in more and more. Also check out the Iron Door Club; very good drummer!
Bad website; http://www.cieh.org/
Information
A. Relevant and Credible i.e. trustworthy author and updated regularly.2
B. Useful and Understandable.2
Operational
A. Speed, Links 2
B. Features 2
Aesthetics
A. layout, 1
B. Colour scheme and readability 1
Overall feeling: 2
Overall Score: 12
Thoughts: This site is certainly not truly awful, but it has several aspects that are very irritating, the text is very small and can strain the eyes, menu’s and the grouping of information are not always logical. The colour scheme is bland and unappealing. From personal experience downloading is a problem and out of date files have been known to be posted from time to time. Having said this there is a lot of information present and the recent addition of the EHN library is a nice feature.
Thursday, 21 January 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment