Hi all, I based my evaluation/assessment on these criteria:
Authority - Author - affiliations, contact information.
Currency - Dated, outdated/dead links, quality of references.
Audience and Purpose - Audience and purpose of information - inform, persuade, sell, etc.
Accuracy - Proper grammar and spelling, relevant links to sources - verifiable.
Objectivity - Biased, sponsor.
Access and Design - Software/hardware requirements, free, registration, logical, easy navigation, loading time.
Good Website: Audit Commission
The author is the Audit Commission with contact details and a brief description of what the Commission does (free objective information intended for all to read) set out clearly. There are no deadlinks (links are relevant), and the information given is informative whilst using good grammar and spelling. The site is arranged logically with choices of navigation given to the reader and does not require registration or additional software/hardware with the load time being good. As an additional bonus the website conforms to the World Wide Webs content Accessibility Guidelines 2.0 to aid those with disabilities.
Bad Website: HavenWorks
This is the worst website ive ever seen, its supposedly an American News website blog but there doesn't appear to be any contact details to verify this. It does have a date and the spelling/grammar seem to be acceptable, but the layout is illogical and its hard to see how anyone could find anything they are looking for. The information that I did read appeared biased and I would doubt the credibility of the sources (especially with outdated links). Despite this, the website is free and requires no registration, nor any additional software/hardware and although the load time at first was bad, this didn't carry on throughout the rest of the website.
Thursday, 21 January 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Hello, i like your evaluation criteria! You have one or two I hadn't actually thought of, for example, the author and whether the website is up to date or not! There are so many things where key information or stats are what you need and you think you've found them but then you discover that the website was made about 5 years ago!
I also thought that your accuracy point was an excellent one. I hate it when you go online and people have spelled the simplest of words incorrectly or used inaccurate grammar.
Julie
Post a Comment