Tuesday, 19 January 2010

Nancy's Website Audit

The Two Websites I Decided to Audit Were:
The Health Protection Agency Website - the Good
The Marcus Cake Website – the Bad and Ugly

This is the Criteria I used to assess the Websites
Clear to Read
Good Links are they active?
Good Site Mapping
Information fits the page
RSS links in place to tell you when the site is updated.
Is the information current
Works on Multiple Brower’s
Has good functionality
It has easy to find contact details
Has no pop ups
Provence issues : Author of the site, does it specify qualifications /expertise
Is their a sponsoring agency group or company
Is it obvious what the purpose of the site is
Is there information on when the site was up-dated

My Thoughts on the Evaluation Method
I decided to judge this criteria qualitatively, rather than quantitatively by using a scoring system. This is because I think I would get more material to justify my choices if asked about the sites. Also using this method I thought it would be easier to play towards my skills.

Site Evaluation: The HPA: The Good
The site itself definitely makes clear what its purpose is. It was clear to read, the right text size and the colours used did not clash making it easy on the eye. The page was laid out well; also making the in take of information easy. The site was to navigate around, including contact details which were in places essay to find which also gave access to email of phone someone direct.

All of the links were live none were broken, when I was being transferred. It also told you when the site was last updated and the information was very current. I think that because this is an important public government website it would have the capacity be used on multiple browsers. So that everyone can access the information.

There were no pop ups causing problems. Importantly provenance was not an issue as it clear could prove all the professionals that worked for the HPA all had recognised qualifications many had PHD’s Masters etc. The sponsorship was not in question as it was a government agency.

Site Evaluation: Marcus Cake: The Bad & Ugly
To begin I was unsure what the site itself and it was about. I had to read for a few minutes to determine this. It wasn’t to clear to read purely because of the font colour used was a very bright blue. Plus there was one side of A4 worth of them down the left side of the page.

I found that these were meant to be links that were meant to take you to the relevant section, but they didn’t work. You had to scroll down manually. As a consequence I didn’t think the site mapping or page layout fitting on all the information was very good. Contact details were very difficult to find to speak to a human contact was all via the web.

I do think it would be compatible with multiple servers because it had feeds to all the social networking sites which universally nearly all browsers use. One plus point is it did have no pop ups although it may just that my virus software stopped them form appearing.

Provence well it did state the provenance of the man that was running the business , which was selling browser software to enable social networking sites . (This is gleaned form my very limited knowledge of computers) . He seems to have done a bit of everything from a degree in economics, a software entrepreneur and an unfinished law degree, which makes me suspicious. I couldn’t find anyone that sponsored the website I am assuming it is the company itself. But the purpose is definitely to sell software. Finally there was no indication was last updated, which is surprising when computer technology is what they deal in.

No comments: